Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best way and how far in advance do I need to place an order?
We will have pre-made cakes ready for same day, next day or two day pickup. However, they are first come (or first call), first serve. Please call us at 781-929-1681 to check flavors, availability and schedule pickup.
For custom orders, we prefer email and an advance notice of at least a week.
Why are your colors so subtle?
We use all natural colors derived from plants, so our colors are not bright. Please expect subtle colors. Because of the same reason, we cannot offer all colors, like red, royal blue, etc.
We also cannot guarantee the color of cupcake liners. If you need a specific colored cupcake liner, please check with us beforehand.
What are your cake sizes?
Our round cake sizes are:
1. 6″ with around 8-10 servings
2. 8″ with around 15-18 servings
3. 10″ with around 25 servings
4. 12″ with around 35-40 servings.
All round cakes are 2 layers. We do 4″ smash cakes only when placed as an order along with the above regular sizes for the same flavor.
Our sheet cake sizes are:
1. Quarter sheet (9X13) – 2 layer with around 35-40 servings
2. Half sheet – 1 layer with around 35-40 servings
Are your products tree nut and peanut free?
We make products that are tree nut and peanut free. However, we work in a facility that has tree nuts, peanuts and other allergens.
Can I taste your products before I place an order?
Absolutely, you can find Melt in Your Mouth products at retail locations listed here.
Do you do wedding cakes?
We make simple wedding cakes which are single tier. We currently do not offer two- or three-tier cakes.
Do you make Disney or other character cakes?
We do not offer fondant cakes as they go against the grain of being all-natural. However, we collaborate with each customer to bring to life their vision or theme using buttercream and/or our other all-natural ingredients. This may include incorporating cake toppers at their direction.
Do I need to refrigerate my cakes or cupcakes?
The cakes and cupcakes do not need to be refrigerated as long as it doesn’t get too hot where they are stored. However, if you do refrigerate them, please bring them to room temperature before serving.
Do you make sugar less cakes?
We can make custom cakes that are sweetened only with fruit or with honey. If you like these cakes to be frosted, the frosting, however will be lightly sweetened with minimal sugar.
Do you deliver?
We offer delivery through Grubhub.
I need my cupcake liners to be a specific color. Can you do that?
We cannot guarantee the color of cupcake liners. If you need a specific colored cupcake liner, please check with us beforehand.
Do you sell gift cards?
Yes. You can purchase gift cards here!